Families Say Meta Hid Teen Safety Files Behind Its Lawyers

Families and school districts suing Meta over social media addiction have asked the federal judge overseeing their cases to sanction the company, saying it hid tens of thousands of internal documents by wrongly labeling them as private conversations with its lawyers. The motion was filed on Friday, November 13, in the federal social media addiction litigation in Oakland, California.

The plaintiffs say Meta used the label to keep research about teens and young users away from families for years. Since a court-ordered review began, Meta has dropped or narrowed its secrecy claims on about 93 percent of the documents reviewed, according to the motion.

What the Families Say Meta Kept Hidden

Companies may keep their private conversations with lawyers out of a lawsuit. This is called attorney-client privilege. The plaintiffs say Meta stretched that protection far beyond its purpose. By the April 2025 deadline for exchanging evidence, Meta had withheld about 130,000 documents in full, the motion says.

The dispute came to a head during the trial brought by state attorneys general in August 2026, which Meta settled before it ended, when Chief Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers called Meta’s redactions in one trial exhibit “entirely inappropriate.” A Meta witness testified that researchers put privilege labels on “anything that [Meta] wouldn’t want the public to see,” according to the motion. The judge later ordered Meta to re-review all of its privilege claims, and in October she appointed a retired judge, Suzanne Segal, as special master to oversee the work. Meta must finish by December 30.

The documents released so far include, according to the plaintiffs:

  • a 2016 slide deck about underage users on Meta’s apps that refers to Mark Zuckerberg and Sheryl Sandberg, previously withheld in full;
  • a 2022 document warning that weak age checks kept young users from getting the safety protections Meta has promoted;
  • a 2023 chat in which Meta employees discussed keeping senior executives away from research because of this litigation; and
  • a 2023 chat that included no lawyer at all.

Much of what these documents say is still blacked out in the public court filing. Other internal Meta records that have already come out in the cases are collected on our Meta internal documents page.

What the Plaintiffs Are Asking For

The motion asks the court to let the plaintiffs use every released document with any trial witness and to block most of Meta’s objections to those documents. It also asks for a jury instruction that would tell jurors about the withholding and let them infer that Meta held the documents back because it believed they would hurt its case. The plaintiffs want a rule that Meta must get the court’s permission before taking back any released document, and they ask for their fees and costs.

Meta has told the court it used computer-assisted review, including generative AI, for part of the re-review, and that it keeps the right to take documents back if they turn out to be privileged after all. In court filings, Meta has said that talk of sanctions is premature, that newly unredacted material in documents the plaintiffs highlighted adds no “key facts,” and that most of the released documents cover subjects already in the record. A Meta spokesperson has called the motion a litigation tactic and said the company volunteered for the re-review. Meta’s written response is due December 2, and the plaintiffs have asked that the motion be heard at a December 14 court conference.

What It Means for Families

The plaintiffs want to use the released documents in the cases now moving toward trial. The first federal trial, brought by the Tucson Unified School District in Arizona, is set to begin on February 8, 2027, and the next trial of young people’s injury claims in the California state court cases in Los Angeles is set for March 16, 2027. See the trial schedule.

The fight is about evidence, not money, and it does not decide any family’s claim. But the injury lawsuits against Meta center on what the company knew about harm to young users and when it knew it, so documents about teen research and underage users bear directly on those claims, the plaintiffs say. As of the November 2 federal court count, 4,309 cases were pending in the federal litigation against Meta, TikTok, Snap and YouTube, including school district cases.

Who May Have a Claim

Families in every state may have a claim. Two things matter most: the young person started using Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, Snapchat or YouTube heavily before age 18 and is now 25 or younger, and a doctor, therapist or counselor diagnosed or treated depression or severe anxiety, an eating disorder or body dysmorphia, or self-harm, suicidal thoughts or a suicide attempt. Families who lost a child may also have a claim. Read more about who may qualify, and keep in mind that claims have filing deadlines.

Doyle APC handles social media addiction claims together with experienced co-counsel.

If you or your child is in crisis, call or text 988 to reach the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline.

Common Questions

What is Meta accused of hiding?

Families and school districts say Meta wrongly withheld internal documents, including research about teens and underage users, by claiming they were private communications with its lawyers. According to the plaintiffs, Meta has since dropped or narrowed its secrecy claims on most of the documents it re-reviewed.

Who decides the sanctions motion?

Chief Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers of the federal court in Oakland, California, who oversees the federal social media addiction cases. The plaintiffs have asked that it be heard on December 14, 2026.

Does this affect my family’s claim?

It does not decide any individual claim. It concerns how the plaintiffs may use documents Meta released as evidence in the cases. Each family still brings its own claim, not a class action.

What compensation can a family seek?

Claims seek medical and counseling expenses, past and future, along with compensation for pain and suffering and loss of enjoyment of life. You pay nothing unless we recover.

Free Case Review